Benzene in acne products and sunscreen: what the lawsuits are really about

In the past few years some of the best known names in skincare have been named in recalls and lawsuits over one chemical: benzene. The headlines were loud. The facts are more precise, and more useful. This is what happened, in plain words.

What is benzene?

Benzene is a chemical found in petrol and tobacco smoke. Health authorities classify it as a human carcinogen. Long or high exposure is linked to leukaemia and other blood cancers. It is never an ingredient in skincare. When it shows up, it is a contaminant.

What is benzoyl peroxide?

Benzoyl peroxide, often shortened to BPO, is one of the most common acne treatments in the world. It kills the bacteria involved in acne. You find it in spot treatments, creams and face washes, usually at 2.5%, 5% or 10%.

The problem is the molecule itself. Benzoyl peroxide is unstable. Under heat, and over time, it can break down and form benzene. A hot car, a sunny bathroom shelf or a warm warehouse can be enough to speed this up.

The acne products: La Roche-Posay, CeraVe and Clearasil

March 2024. Valisure, an independent laboratory in the United States, tested benzoyl peroxide acne products and reported that some could form benzene at many times the FDA limit of 2 parts per million. It asked the FDA to recall the products.

The lawsuits. Consumers then filed class actions against several companies. Among them: L'Oréal, for acne products from its brands La Roche-Posay and CeraVe, and RB Health, the maker of Clearasil. The claim was that these products could contain benzene and that buyers were not warned.

March 2025. The FDA ran its own tests on 95 benzoyl peroxide acne products. More than 90% had no detectable benzene or extremely low levels. Six products were recalled from shops, including one lot of La Roche-Posay Effaclar Duo. L'Oréal removed the remaining stock of that formula and announced a new one.

What was not proven. No CeraVe product was recalled. The companies dispute the claims. In 2026 a federal judge dismissed the consolidated case against L'Oréal, ruling that federal law overrides the state law claims. The FDA has said that the cancer risk from these products is very low, even with daily use over many years.

The sunscreens: Neutrogena and Aveeno

This story started earlier and has a different cause. In 2021 Valisure found benzene in several sunscreens. Johnson & Johnson then recalled five aerosol sunscreens from its Neutrogena and Aveeno brands. Consumer lawsuits followed and were settled, without the company admitting liability.

The difference matters. In the sunscreens, the benzene came from contaminated raw materials. In the acne products, it can come from the active ingredient itself.

What this means for you

  • Read the active ingredient. On acne products, look for "benzoyl peroxide" on the label.
  • Keep it cool. If you use a benzoyl peroxide product, store it away from heat and sunlight, and do not keep it past its expiry date.
  • Check recalls. The FDA publishes the recalled lots. A recall concerns specific lots, not a whole brand.
  • Do not panic. Most tested products were fine. This is a reason to read labels, not a reason to fear your bathroom shelf.

Where we stand

We do not use benzoyl peroxide in any Skin Alliance formula. We believe the safest ingredient list is one you can read and understand, and that a product should stay what it is from the day it is made to the day you finish it. Everything we leave out, and why, is in The Never List.

Sources

  • U.S. Food and Drug Administration, testing of benzoyl peroxide acne products and retail recalls, March 2025
  • Valisure, citizen petition on benzene in benzoyl peroxide products, March 2024
  • In re L'Oréal Benzoyl Peroxide Products Litigation, U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York
  • O'Dea v. RB Health (US) LLC, proposed class action on Clearasil products
  • Johnson & Johnson Consumer Inc., voluntary recall of Neutrogena and Aveeno aerosol sunscreens, July 2021

This article describes public recalls and court cases. Allegations in lawsuits are claims, not findings. It is not medical or legal advice.